Come Rack, Come Rope by Robert Hugh Benson is a powerful historical novel that plunges the reader into the intense religious persecution of Catholics in Elizabethan England. I recently revisited this book with my Tuesday Night Classics Club, and on this second read, I was again struck by the beauty of Benson’s writing and the emotional depth of the characters.
The story centers on Robin and Marjorie, two young Catholics who display extraordinary courage in the face of mounting danger. Their commitment to their faith, even when it costs them everything, is deeply moving. Benson’s portrayal of their heroism, particularly Marjorie’s steadfastness and Robin’s inner conflict as he chooses between love and duty, makes the novel both gripping and poignant.
One of the novel’s great strengths is its inclusion of real historical figures, such as the martyr Edmund Campion, which grounds the narrative in reality and heightens its sense of urgency. Benson masterfully weaves these real-life events with the fictional struggles of Robin’s father, whose internal battle as a recusant—torn between clinging to his faith and giving in to pressure—adds layers of complexity to the story.
This is a novel best suited for teenage readers and older, as it deals with mature themes of religious persecution, martyrdom, and moral choices. It offers not only an engaging narrative but also a profound window into a dark chapter of history. For anyone interested in faith, history, or stories of courage in the face of adversity, Come Rack, Come Rope is a deeply rewarding read.
https://plumfieldmoms.com/plumfield-moms-book-reviews/come-rack-come-rope